Ratist Community Rating
No reviews yet
Your Score Estimate
Rate a few books to unlock your estimate
Community breakdown
Bars show the community-aggregated score per category. Rate this book to contribute.
This thesis examines the production and problematisation of the boundaries o~ organic pol itical metaphor in Renaissance England. What was the status of the Other in the articulation of national and cultural identity? Was it merely the negative component constitutive of that identity, the 'unnatural' category that defined the 'natural'? Or was the trace of the Other recognisable within the social body, thereby problematising the boundary that separated the socio-symbol ic categories of inside and outside? In resorting to organic pol itical metaphor, Tudor and Stuart authority repeatedly blurred such distinctions. Through readings of I iterary and non-I iterary texts, but with particular attention to the plays of Thomas Dekker and Wi I I iam Shakespeare, I argue that this confusion was two-fold. First of all, rather than using the notion of the body pol itic to illust"r ate the harmony and hierarchies of the state (as had been the case in the Middle Ages), Tudor and Stuart authorities increasingly employed it as a pathological metaphor which above al I emphasised the need for containment, the imposition of 'classical' boundaries upon a naturally 'grotesque' organism. The 'unnatural', therefore, was identifiable within the boundaries of the 'natural', if only as a prelude to its seemingly irrevocable expulsion. But at a second-order level, the authorities' gestures of containment frequently reinscribed the 'unnatural' su~version they sought to el iminate. Such gestures were figured in terms that invoked the most ambivalent or 'grotesque' functions of the body, where the categories of inside and outside tended to be fused and confused: purgation, feeding, 'leaking', speaking. Moreover, these functions were also associated with marginal groups and objects, neither 'inside' nor 'outside' the Engl ish body pol itic: Jewish doctors, Irish costermongers, prostitutes, condu its, witches, Catho I i cs. A cer ta in specu I ar i ty thus un i ted authority and the marginal figures of Renaissance society. Rather than initiating a mise en abime of undecidable identity, however, this specularity highl ighted the contradictions inherent in Tudor and Stuart authority's deployment of organic metaphor.
