Recollections of the table-talk of Samuel Rogers. To which is added Porsoniana. Third edition

Community breakdown

Bars show the community-aggregated score per category. Rate this book to contribute.

8vo. pp. xvi, 357. Cloth. Inscribed by C. Stocks on half title. A selection, compiled from Alexander Dyce’s own memory, of Samuel Rogers’s table talk over breakfast in London. The anecdotes of Richard Porson were communicated to the editor by William Maltby. Dyce’s work received a devastating notice in The Times of 27 February, charging the editor with misrepresenting Rogers and degrading his celebrated eloquence. The Athenaeum soon published a similar attack on 1 March, and John Payne Collier took the opportunity to supply an anecdote – true or false – lending credence to a challenged passage in Table Talk, which he withdrew because The Athenaeum preferred to print another letter on the matter. Dyce himself asked to publish Collier’s letter in the preface to his third edition. Nevertheless, seven months later, Collier went ahead with a laborious assault on Dyce in Seven Lectures (see Bib# 4117168/Fr# 990 in this collection). See A. & J. Freeman, John Payne Collier. Scholarship and Forgery in the Nineteenth Century. New Haven, 2004, I, pp. 713-714. Click here to view the Johns Hopkins University catalog record.